Should You Sell to PSA? My First Buyback Offers (Real Numbers + Tips)

14/10/2025 16 min Episodio 84
Should You Sell to PSA? My First Buyback Offers (Real Numbers + Tips)

Listen "Should You Sell to PSA? My First Buyback Offers (Real Numbers + Tips)"

Episode Synopsis


Tried PSA’s new buyback on a fresh 17-card submission. They offered on 3 slabs; I sold 1 and passed on 2. Here’s the exact math, comps logic, and my quick framework so you can decide when to take the offer and when to hold.Timestamps 0:00 Intro — PSA’s buyback in plain English 0:52 The 3 offers (Brink / Strickland / Brady) 2:48 Why I accepted the Strickland 4:05 Why I passed on Brink + Brady 5:10 My “Offer vs Net” checklist (use this!) 6:40 Is this good for the hobby? 7:35 Top 5 times I’d take PSA’s offer 8:30 Final takeaways + next steps
Thanks to our monthly supporters

Tater
Justin Burch
Always_Eaton
Chris Crimminger
Casey Miller
Ryan Bruder
Kevin Quiles
Evan Hastie
Donut
Josh Stewart

More episodes of the podcast Sports Cards are Dope