Evaluating Performance Reviews

24/06/2025 22 min Episodio 119
Evaluating Performance Reviews

Listen "Evaluating Performance Reviews"

Episode Synopsis

"Rate results, not personality. Measurable goals create clarity and eliminate the drama." Notable Moments 02:03 – Common complaints about performance evaluations 04:15 – Why rating personality traits is subjective and flawed 06:54 – Jody's real-world example of objective goal-setting 09:59 – The value of goal-based evaluations 13:35 – Why tardiness and similar issues must be addressed in real-time 14:59 – The power of evaluation discussions 17:49 – A clear framework for monthly check-ins and progress 18:42 – How to introduce a new review system to your team 20:10 – Getting help with building your evaluation system Performance reviews don't have to be awkward or ineffective. In this episode, Tim and Jody unpack the flaws of traditional evaluation models, especially those based on subjective personality ratings. They investigate the better alternative of goal-based evaluations. Tim explains why focusing on measurable objectives improves clarity and eliminates unnecessary conflict. The episode covers how to structure and roll out a new evaluation process, what to communicate with your team, and how leaders can make reviews a helpful conversation rather than a dreaded formality. Read the blog for more from this episode.  Connect with Tim and his team: Website: https://bestculturesolutions.ca/ LinkedIn: Best Culture Solutions, Inc Instagram: @best.culture.solutions   Email: [email protected]