Way-Too-Early Heisman Picks: Who’s the Best Bet for 2025?

17/03/2025 20 min Episodio 108
Way-Too-Early Heisman Picks: Who’s the Best Bet for 2025?

Listen "Way-Too-Early Heisman Picks: Who’s the Best Bet for 2025?"

Episode Synopsis


In this episode of Saturday vs Sunday, Geoff Dover and John Barban dive into the way-too-early 2025 Heisman race, breaking down the favorites, value picks, and longshot contenders to win college football’s most prestigious award. With the transfer portal still in play and rosters not yet set, this episode is all about finding early value before the odds shift.Breaking Down the Heisman FavoritesThe guys start with the top Heisman betting favorites, led by Arch Manning (+750), despite never having started a college game. Texas is expected to be strong, but is Manning worth betting on at such low odds? Other top names include Garrett Nussmeier (LSU), Cade Klubnik (Clemson), and Drew Aller (Penn State).While these quarterbacks have the talent and team strength to contend, Jeff and John discuss the historical trend of first-year starters struggling to win the award. Could Manning or another unproven QB break that pattern?Value Picks: Who’s Worth a Bet?Next, the guys highlight players with legitimate Heisman potential at great odds. Their top two value bets: • Lenore Sellers (South Carolina, +2000) – A big, mobile, dual-threat QB with the ability to take over games, Sellers showed flashes of dominance last season and could put up Heisman-caliber numbers in the SEC. • DJ Lagway (Florida, +2200) – One of the most physically gifted QBs in the country, Lagway closed last season strong and plays in a program with multiple Heisman winners in its history. If Florida stays competitive in the SEC, he could be a serious contender.Both QBs offer the dual-threat skill set that has dominated recent Heisman winners, and playing in the SEC means plenty of high-profile, “Heisman moment” games.Official Picks: Who Are Jeff & John Betting On?After breaking down the favorites and mid-range bets, the guys make their official Heisman picks: • John’s Pick: DJ Lagway (Florida, +2200) – With Florida’s rich Heisman history, an improving roster, and an exciting playstyle, Lagway is a great bet at these odds. • Jeff’s Pick: Nico Iamaleava (Tennessee, +1600) – Tennessee’s offense is built to rack up points, and their schedule may help Nico outperform Georgia’s QB. If Tennessee wins the SEC, he has a clear path to the trophy.Dark Horses & Longshots: Can Anyone Shock the World?Jeff and John also discuss big-risk, high-reward Heisman bets, including: • Bryce Underwood (Michigan, +6000) – The highly touted freshman could thrive in Michigan’s system. If he wins the starting job, he’ll have the schedule to create Heisman moments. • Jalon Daniels (Kansas, +6000) – A proven dual-threat QB on a non-traditional powerhouse, but Kansas may not win enough games for him to truly contend. • Daman Williams Jr. (Washington, +10,000) – A total flyer, but flashed serious potential late last season.Final TakeawaysWith so many first-year starters in the mix, the 2025 Heisman race could be one of the most unpredictable in years. Will Manning live up to the hype? Can an SEC QB dominate? And will a dark horse contender rise to steal the trophy?Jeff and John break it all down in this must-listen episode for college football fans and bettors looking for early Heisman value.

More episodes of the podcast Saturday vs Sunday