The $50 Investment Lie: Why Your Credit Score is Crashing While Wall Street Gets Easy 🤯

03/10/2025 5 min

Listen "The $50 Investment Lie: Why Your Credit Score is Crashing While Wall Street Gets Easy 🤯"

Episode Synopsis

Enjoying the show? Support our mission and help keep the content coming by buying us a coffee.Today, we're confronting a strange and unsettling duality happening in the world of personal finance: while investing has become easier and cheaper than ever before, consumer credit health is in a crisis state, dropping at the fastest rate since the 2009 financial crisis.We're unpacking this tension—the ease of building wealth versus the crushing weight of debt—to give you clarity on where the real financial risks and opportunities lie in 2025.For beginners, building wealth is now more accessible than at any other time in history. We highlight the low-effort, high-impact strategies making this possible:The 401K Match: The single best investment available, as it is essentially free money from your employer that instantly doubles your investment. You have to grab it.Automated, Low-Cost Management: Robo-advisors like Betterment and Wealthfront use algorithms to manage passive growth portfolios (like S&P 500 index funds) for annual fees as low as 0.25%. Historically, the S&P 500 has averaged returns of 9.8% over the last two decades.The Democratization of Investing: The rise of fractional shares completely removes the old barrier of needing thousands of dollars to buy expensive stocks (like Amazon or Google). Now, you can invest just $50 and get a fraction of a share, making diversification and systematic dollar-cost averaging simple and consistent, even for those with small budgets.Micro-Investing: Apps like Acorns allow investing to happen in the background, rounding up everyday purchases and automatically investing the difference.Despite the ease of investing, the data on consumer debt is terrifying. For the first time in over a decade, the average US FICO score has dropped for two consecutive years, falling to 715 in April 2025. This two-point drop is the fastest rate of decline since 2009.This decline is driven by two main forces:Soaring Credit Utilization: The percentage of available credit being used (Credit Utilization Ratio) jumped sharply to 35.5%—significantly higher than the recommended 30%. This is hard evidence that sustained inflation and high interest rates are forcing people to run their credit cards closer to the limit.Increased Delinquencies: The rate of serious debt problems (90 days late or more) has hit 9.8%. A significant portion of this surge is due to student loan debt finally hitting credit reports in early 2025 after the pandemic forbearance ended.The pain of this crisis is hitting Gen Z the hardest. Their average FICO scores dropped at double the rate seen just four years prior, averaging three points down. This is largely structural: they lack the time to build savings buffers and are immediately vulnerable to high prices and high interest rates due to larger student loan loads.This is the core of the financial duality: high-tech ease for investing is meaningless if crippling consumer debt is eating up any potential gains. The system works for saving, but it is brutally punishing for carrying debt.We leave you with a crucial final thought: The cost of poor credit health—the higher interest rates that come with a lower FICO score—is a powerful counterforce to your investment efforts. Given this rapid decline in average scores across the country, how much is poor credit actually costing you in potential investment returns?