Listen "235. The Urge: The Shaping of Addiction & Mental Health with Carl Erik Fisher"
Episode Synopsis
According to the National Center for Drug Abuse Statistics, since 2000, the United States has experienced over 700,000 deaths due to drug overdose. Addiction and substance use disorders are at the root of this enormous loss, and about half of people who struggle with substance use disorder will experience some mental health disorder during their life. And vice versa—many individuals struggling with mental health disorders also struggle with various forms of addiction.
Carl Erik Fisher, author of The Urge: Our History of Addiction, has expertise in law, ethics, and policy related to psychiatry and neuroscience. His personal struggle with addiction in combination with his professional expertise converges to help us understand the forces that have shaped addiction throughout our history. On this episode of POTC, Carl and Yael discuss the social contingencies and historical contexts that lead to addiction, substance use disorder, and co-morbid mental health issues. Join us in this episode to learn more about commonly held beliefs about addiction, prescribers’ blind spots to certain medications, and much much more!
Listen and Learn:
Yael and Debbie discuss the importance of contextualizing human behavior
How society tends to neglect the historical context of addictive behaviors (and why it’s so important to overcome this neglect)
The issues that come with treating addiction differently than other mental health disorders
Practical advice for clinicians and patients working with co-morbid addiction and other mental health disorders
Carl provides insights on how addiction has been weaponized to serve corporations and politicians
An important, historical example of what happens when scientists and researchers rigidly adopt a particular view (read: biases) but find information that conflicts with that view
The expert-approved definition of harm reduction
Carl answers commonly held beliefs about addiction (e.g., is addiction a brain disease?)
How Carl, a practicing psychiatrist with an in-depth knowledge of the history of addiction and mental health, approaches prescription by balancing values, change, and harm reduction
Things consumers should know about prescribers’ blind spots to certain medications
Carl’s personal story of addiction and recovery
What to consider when balancing evidence- and RCT-based treatments with clients’ individuality and choices
Practical advice for helping those who are in denial of their substance abuse problem
Resources:
Read Carl’s book, The Urge: Our History of Addiction!
Check out Carl's recent New York Times piece, Why It's misleading to call addiction a disease
Listen to Carl’s podcast, Flourishing After Addiction!
Read RAND reports on drug policy research, prescription drug abuse, and substance abuse
Grab your copy of all our favorite books at bookshop.org/shop/offtheclockpsych.
Check out Debbie, Jill’s, Yael, and Diana, websites to access their offerings, sign up for their newsletters, buy their books, and more!
About Carl Erik Fisher:
Carl Erik Fisher (USA), psychiatrist and author of The Urge: A History of Addiction, New York, May 24, 2021. Photograph © Beowulf Sheehan
Carl Erik Fisher, M.D., is an addiction psychiatrist, bioethics scholar, and author of The Urge: Our History of Addiction. He is an assistant professor of clinical psychiatry at Columbia University, where he studies and teaches law, ethics, and policy relating to psychiatry and neuroscience. He received his B.A. in Music (vocal performance) and Biology from the University of North Carolina, his M.D. from the Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, and completed psychiatric residency at Columbia University. He then completed fellowship training in forensic psychiatry in the Columbia/Cornell Residency in Psychiatry and the Law. Carl’s scholarly work addresses the role of neuroscience and psychiatry in society,
Carl Erik Fisher, author of The Urge: Our History of Addiction, has expertise in law, ethics, and policy related to psychiatry and neuroscience. His personal struggle with addiction in combination with his professional expertise converges to help us understand the forces that have shaped addiction throughout our history. On this episode of POTC, Carl and Yael discuss the social contingencies and historical contexts that lead to addiction, substance use disorder, and co-morbid mental health issues. Join us in this episode to learn more about commonly held beliefs about addiction, prescribers’ blind spots to certain medications, and much much more!
Listen and Learn:
Yael and Debbie discuss the importance of contextualizing human behavior
How society tends to neglect the historical context of addictive behaviors (and why it’s so important to overcome this neglect)
The issues that come with treating addiction differently than other mental health disorders
Practical advice for clinicians and patients working with co-morbid addiction and other mental health disorders
Carl provides insights on how addiction has been weaponized to serve corporations and politicians
An important, historical example of what happens when scientists and researchers rigidly adopt a particular view (read: biases) but find information that conflicts with that view
The expert-approved definition of harm reduction
Carl answers commonly held beliefs about addiction (e.g., is addiction a brain disease?)
How Carl, a practicing psychiatrist with an in-depth knowledge of the history of addiction and mental health, approaches prescription by balancing values, change, and harm reduction
Things consumers should know about prescribers’ blind spots to certain medications
Carl’s personal story of addiction and recovery
What to consider when balancing evidence- and RCT-based treatments with clients’ individuality and choices
Practical advice for helping those who are in denial of their substance abuse problem
Resources:
Read Carl’s book, The Urge: Our History of Addiction!
Check out Carl's recent New York Times piece, Why It's misleading to call addiction a disease
Listen to Carl’s podcast, Flourishing After Addiction!
Read RAND reports on drug policy research, prescription drug abuse, and substance abuse
Grab your copy of all our favorite books at bookshop.org/shop/offtheclockpsych.
Check out Debbie, Jill’s, Yael, and Diana, websites to access their offerings, sign up for their newsletters, buy their books, and more!
About Carl Erik Fisher:
Carl Erik Fisher (USA), psychiatrist and author of The Urge: A History of Addiction, New York, May 24, 2021. Photograph © Beowulf Sheehan
Carl Erik Fisher, M.D., is an addiction psychiatrist, bioethics scholar, and author of The Urge: Our History of Addiction. He is an assistant professor of clinical psychiatry at Columbia University, where he studies and teaches law, ethics, and policy relating to psychiatry and neuroscience. He received his B.A. in Music (vocal performance) and Biology from the University of North Carolina, his M.D. from the Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, and completed psychiatric residency at Columbia University. He then completed fellowship training in forensic psychiatry in the Columbia/Cornell Residency in Psychiatry and the Law. Carl’s scholarly work addresses the role of neuroscience and psychiatry in society,
More episodes of the podcast Transcripts
429. May Contain Lies with Alex Edmans
15/10/2025
423. Collective Edge with Colin Fisher
03/09/2025
422. Mindwise with Nicholas Epley
27/08/2025
ZARZA We are Zarza, the prestigious firm behind major projects in information technology.