4. Too Deep for Small Talk (Part One) - Why We Crave Depth and Struggle on the Surface

08/09/2025 38 min Episodio 4

Listen "4. Too Deep for Small Talk (Part One) - Why We Crave Depth and Struggle on the Surface"

Episode Synopsis

Ever felt like you’re too serious to enjoy everyday chit-chat? Too awkward to keep small talk flowing? Too deep to feel satisfied by the surface stuff?Yeah. Us too.In this episode of Too Much, Apparently, we (Carly and Alice — two therapists and recovering perfectionists with squishy brains) get real about why small talk feels exhausting, why depth feels nourishing, and what it’s like to long for connection in a world that often prefers keeping things light.We unpack our teenage memories, awkward family gatherings, existential spirals mid-conversation, and that magical feeling when something you say actually lands.This time we talked about:🎙️ We’ve felt this thing too (and we still do): struggling with small talk at family events, joking about mortality in the wrong moment, and laughing way too hard at our own jokes.👀 What it looks like in real life: standing in silence after going “too deep,” feeling on the outside in groups, or lighting up when someone finally meets you in the big conversations.🧠 Why our brains do it: sensitivity, nervous system wiring, neurodivergence, past experiences of not belonging, and the search for meaning.🧍🏽‍♀️🧍🏻 The different ways it shows up: craving vulnerability, asking big questions too soon, longing for real connection, and sometimes masking with humour or deflection.🧰 Coping mechanisms: inviting others to depth gently, finding “your people,” using humour as a bridge, and making peace with being different.🌱 How to make peace with it: Wanting depth isn’t a flaw — it’s how some of us are wired to connect, and that’s something worth valuing.BOOK MENTIONED: BETTER SMALL TALK BY PATRICK KINGThanks for listening           💛💜🩷🩵🧡💬 New episodes every Monday.🎧 Follow now to join the conversation.🧡 CONNECT WITH US 🎙️ Podcast socials: → Instagram: @toomuchapparently → TikTok: @toomuchapparently → YouTube: Too Much, Apparently → Website: www.toomuchapparently.com👩‍💻 Carly Radford: → Website: www.carlyradford.com → Instagram: @the_sensitivity_therapist👩🏻‍💻 Alice Tew: → Website: www.alicetew.com → Instagram: @reparentingwithalice📩 Email us: [email protected] 🗓️ New episodes every MondayThis is a podcast that says: bring your too-muchness… we’re here for it.Disclaimer: Just a quick note to say this podcast isn’t therapy, and it’s not a substitute for professional support. We’re here to share ideas and experiences, but if you’re struggling, please reach out to a mental health professional or a support service near you.—--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------sensitivity podcast, overthinking podcast, perfectionism podcast, therapy podcast, anxiety podcast, emotional podcast, mental health podcast, deep chat podcast, neurodivergent podcast, autism podcast, adhd podcast, audhd podcast, Too Much Apparently podcast

More episodes of the podcast Too Much, Apparently