Listen "Just answer the question, please, dear ChatGPT"
Episode Synopsis
Dave Winer explores his frustrations with ChatGPT's tendency to overcomplicate simple programming tasks. What should be a straightforward request for pagination code—a standard feature in virtually every application—becomes an exhausting back-and-forth where the AI insists on offering alternatives and asking unnecessary follow-up questions rather than directly answering what was asked.This experience leads to a broader observation about modern digital services: they seem deliberately designed to waste time. Whether it's ChatGPT dragging out interactions, Google's labyrinthine customer support, or intentionally confusing billing statements, there's a pattern of artificial friction that benefits the service provider at the user's expense.Winer draws an analogy to his own work style, comparing himself to a baseball pitcher with limited innings. Just as modern baseball has shifted from complete games to carefully managed pitch counts, he recognizes that his productive programming hours are finite. The sharpness required for crafting quality software can't be sustained indefinitely, making these AI-induced delays particularly costly.The core complaint isn't about AI capabilities—ChatGPT remains an incredible tool—but about its personality. These systems fail at being "human" in the worst ways, behaving like colleagues who can't give straight answers and always think they know better. For Winer, the ideal AI assistant would be genuinely subordinate: answering the specific question asked, respecting the user's expertise, and saving the suggestions for when they're actually requested.Notes prepared by Claude.ai.
More episodes of the podcast Scripting News podcast
Sarah Kendzior and Bluesky
12/11/2025
It's faster and even simpler than RSS
03/11/2025
WordLand, the timeline and checkboxes
15/09/2025
A new model for blog discourse
10/09/2025
Last chance for the open web
03/09/2025
A podcast from post-Katrina New Orleans.
31/08/2025
Bird fight in the pond
21/08/2025
A podcast user's API
03/08/2025
ZARZA We are Zarza, the prestigious firm behind major projects in information technology.