The Grudge (2004) Review: Is It Actually Scary?

01/11/2023 28 min Temporada 2 Episodio 21
The Grudge (2004) Review: Is It Actually Scary?

Listen "The Grudge (2004) Review: Is It Actually Scary?"

Episode Synopsis


In this Halloween special of Scream Creeps, Jeremy, Josh, and Aaron dress up (as Slytherin, Nacho Libre, and Peter Parker) to review the 2004 American remake of The Grudge. Ranked #21 on the "Science of Scare" list, the team debates whether this J-Horror adaptation deserves its high placement or if nostalgia has painted it scarier than it really is.The discussion highlights the film's confusing non-linear storytelling, with the hosts admitting they struggled to piece together the plot—specifically the connection between the "meowing" boy, Toshio, and the murdered cat—until the halfway point. While they agree the movie isn't terrifying by modern standards (noting a low heart rate increase of only 6 BPM), they praise the iconic sound design of the "death rattle" and the creepy visuals of Kayako. Key scenes discussed include the jawless girl on the stairs, the shower hand scene, and the hanging body sequence. The episode wraps up with a look ahead to their highly anticipated review of Five Nights at Freddy's.Key Highlights [00:28] Halloween Costumes: The hosts show off their costumes: Jeremy as a Slytherin student, Aaron as Peter Parker, and Josh as Nacho Libre (complete with "nipple-proof" shirt). [01:17] Production & Reception: A breakdown of the film's massive box office success ($187 million on a $10 million budget) despite mixed critical reviews. [05:37] The Cat Boy Confusion: The crew discusses their confusion over Toshio, the boy who meows like a cat, and the eventual reveal of the father's murder spree involving the family pet. [10:29] The Death Rattle: A conversation on the film's most effective scare tactic: the croaking/gargling sound made by the ghost, which Josh admits to mimicking to scare people in real life. [13:19] The Jawless Girl: The team reacts to the shocking practical effect of the girl with the missing jaw, agreeing it was one of the few genuinely "cool" visual moments. [15:36] Science of Scare Stats: Jeremy reveals the heart rate data: a resting BPM of 65 and a movie average of 71, proving the film wasn't physically stressing the test subjects very much.

More episodes of the podcast Scream Creeps