Listen "How the Plastic Panic Hurts Us—and the Planet"
Episode Synopsis
John Tierney joins Brian Anderson to discuss the campaign to ban the use of plastic products and the flawed logic behind the recycling movement—the subjects of Tierney’s story, “The Perverse Panic over Plastic,” from the Winter 2020 Issue of City Journal.
Hundreds of cities and eight states have outlawed or regulated single-use plastic bags. But according to Tierney, the plastic panic doesn’t make sense. Plastic bags are the best environmental choice at the supermarket, not the worst, and cities that built expensive recycling programs—in the hopes of turning a profit on recycled products—have instead paid extra to get rid of their plastic waste, mostly by shipping it to Asian countries with low labor costs. However, the bans will likely continue as political leaders and private companies seek a renewed sense of moral superiority.
Hundreds of cities and eight states have outlawed or regulated single-use plastic bags. But according to Tierney, the plastic panic doesn’t make sense. Plastic bags are the best environmental choice at the supermarket, not the worst, and cities that built expensive recycling programs—in the hopes of turning a profit on recycled products—have instead paid extra to get rid of their plastic waste, mostly by shipping it to Asian countries with low labor costs. However, the bans will likely continue as political leaders and private companies seek a renewed sense of moral superiority.
More episodes of the podcast City Journal Audio
The City Journal Podcast: A Year in Review
31/12/2025
City Journal Podcast Highlights
24/12/2025
Enduring Lessons of Christmas
17/12/2025
Mamdani’s Extreme Ideas
11/12/2025
How Did Zohran Mamdani Win?
19/11/2025
Inside the DSA’s Growing Influence
12/11/2025
City Journal Reacts to Election Night
05/11/2025
City Journal’s New College Rankings
29/10/2025
ZARZA We are Zarza, the prestigious firm behind major projects in information technology.