1. Conference. Listen to the entire track once and complete the three columns.
- The concession
- The dispensable paragraph
- The hinge
- The consequence
- The real thesis of the speaker
Show answers
- The collectors were paid by result, so the returns are suspect.
- The surviving books were rebound in the eighteen nineties.
- The returns agree with the parish registers in eleven counties.
- The standard account survives, but for different reasons.
- The account is right and the usual justification for it is wrong.
2. Debate. Listen to the entire track and note what each intervention does with the previous one.
- Intervention 2 (concedes and redirects · questions the premise · corrects a term · repeats the first)
- Intervention 3 (concedes and redirects · questions the premise · corrects a term · repeats the first)
- Intervention 4 (concedes and redirects · questions the premise · corrects a term · repeats the first)
- What is the word at the center of the entire debate?
- Who changes the ground of the discussion?
Show answers
- concedes and redirects
- questions the premise
- corrects a term
- fairness
- The third speaker, by questioning the criterion itself.
3. Dense text. Break down each sentence and write its version in simple sentences.
- Notwithstanding the reservations expressed at the time, the revised household estimates, prepared without access to the original returns, remain in use.
- It is generally accepted, though seldom demonstrated, that the second compiler worked from a copy.
- Rebound in 1904 and catalogued twice since, the ledger no longer shows which pages were removed.
- Nor, insofar as the surviving correspondence tells us anything, did the compilers ever meet.
Show answers
- People expressed reservations at the time. The estimates were revised without the original returns. They are still in use.
- Most scholars accept this, but few have shown it. The second compiler worked from a copy.
- The ledger was rebound in 1904 and catalogued twice. It no longer shows which pages were removed.
- The surviving letters tell us little. As far as they go, the compilers never met.
4. Listen to the entire track and decide, for each sentence, whether it is a concession, a turn or a consequence.
- Phrase 1 (concession · turn · consequence)
- Phrase 2 (concession · turn · consequence)
- Phrase 3 (concession · turn · consequence)
- Phrase 4 (concession · turn · consequence)
- Phrase 5 (concession · turn · consequence)
- Phrase 6 (concession · turn · consequence)
Show answers
- concession
- turn
- consequence
- concession
- turn
- consequence
5. Oral production. Record yourself and check each criterion.
- Summarise a twenty-minute talk in four sentences
- Concede a point and then turn against it
- Say one sentence with a low parenthesis inside it
- Open a new section of a talk aloud
- Ask a question that challenges a premise, not a fact
Show answers
- Their own response. The criteria: one sentence for the concession, one for the hinge, one for the consequence, and one for the real thesis.
- Their own response. The criterion: the concession must be the strongest version of the opposing argument, not a weakened version.
- Their own response. The criterion: the section must lower its tone and speed up, and the main thread must remain audible above.
- Their own response. The criteria: long pause, high start, and a phrase that announces the content of the section.
- Their own response. The criterion: the question must call into question the criterion used, not a specific piece of data from the presentation.