1. Listen to the entire track and write down, for each sentence, what piece of information is presented without being stated.
- Phrase 1
- Phrase 2
- Phrase 3
- Phrase 4
- Phrase 5
Show answers
- The contractor used to invoice monthly
- The auditors were the least likely to accept it
- The earlier survey was never filed
- The department had written to the minister before
- Somebody changed the drawings
2. Rewrite each direct sentence as a praise that condemns, without using any negative words.
- He is a poor analyst but he arrives on time.
- Her presentation was dull and far too long.
- The design is unoriginal and copies our competitors.
- He used to miss deadlines and has only just improved.
- The decision was reckless and nobody supported it.
Show answers
- He is always punctual, and his files are beautifully kept
- Her presentation was thorough, and it covered every possible detail
- The design is reassuringly familiar to anyone in the sector
- He has stopped missing deadlines this year
- It was a brave decision to take without any support
3. Refute the presupposition first, and then respond.
- Why did your team stop checking the second appendix?
- How long has the department been hiding these figures?
- When did you realise the survey had been falsified?
- Who told you to leave the engineer off the list again?
Show answers
- We never stopped: the appendix was checked at every stage
- Nothing has been hidden, and the figures were published in March
- The survey was not falsified, so there was nothing to realise
- Nobody instructed me, and the engineer was never left off
4. Free production. Write, apply the two tests, and then say it out loud.
- Write a four line reference that praises nothing important.
- Underline one presupposition in your own reference.
- Cancel one implicature in your text without contradicting yourself.
- Say one sentence twice, first closed and then with reservation.
- Rewrite the reference so that it says exactly what you mean.
Show answers
- Their own response. Not a negative word; the effect has to come from what is not mentioned.
- Its own response. Check it by negating the sentence: if the information still stands, it is a presupposition.
- Their own response. If adding "in fact, the opposite" makes the sentence absurd, it was a presupposition and cannot be canceled.
- Their own response. The second one with a fall-rise, without adding any "but": the reservation goes in the melody.
- Their own response. An explicit and verifiable judgment is expected, which is what an honest reference demands.