Skip to content

C2 · Unit 7 · Practice

Practice: writing what isn’t said

Producing and dismantling texts with implicit content: a lukewarm reference, a response that rejects the framework, and a reservation expressed solely through tone.

Do the four exercises in a row. The first three are self-correcting; the fourth does not have a key because what is being evaluated is whether your text withstands the cancellation test and the negation test. Write it and apply the two tests to it yourself.

1. Listen to the entire track and write down, for each sentence, what piece of information is presented without being stated.

  1. Phrase 1
  2. Phrase 2
  3. Phrase 3
  4. Phrase 4
  5. Phrase 5
Show answers
  1. The contractor used to invoice monthly
  2. The auditors were the least likely to accept it
  3. The earlier survey was never filed
  4. The department had written to the minister before
  5. Somebody changed the drawings

2. Rewrite each direct sentence as a praise that condemns, without using any negative words.

  1. He is a poor analyst but he arrives on time.
  2. Her presentation was dull and far too long.
  3. The design is unoriginal and copies our competitors.
  4. He used to miss deadlines and has only just improved.
  5. The decision was reckless and nobody supported it.
Show answers
  1. He is always punctual, and his files are beautifully kept
  2. Her presentation was thorough, and it covered every possible detail
  3. The design is reassuringly familiar to anyone in the sector
  4. He has stopped missing deadlines this year
  5. It was a brave decision to take without any support

3. Refute the presupposition first, and then respond.

  1. Why did your team stop checking the second appendix?
  2. How long has the department been hiding these figures?
  3. When did you realise the survey had been falsified?
  4. Who told you to leave the engineer off the list again?
Show answers
  1. We never stopped: the appendix was checked at every stage
  2. Nothing has been hidden, and the figures were published in March
  3. The survey was not falsified, so there was nothing to realise
  4. Nobody instructed me, and the engineer was never left off

4. Free production. Write, apply the two tests, and then say it out loud.

  1. Write a four line reference that praises nothing important.
  2. Underline one presupposition in your own reference.
  3. Cancel one implicature in your text without contradicting yourself.
  4. Say one sentence twice, first closed and then with reservation.
  5. Rewrite the reference so that it says exactly what you mean.
Show answers
  1. Their own response. Not a negative word; the effect has to come from what is not mentioned.
  2. Its own response. Check it by negating the sentence: if the information still stands, it is a presupposition.
  3. Their own response. If adding "in fact, the opposite" makes the sentence absurd, it was a presupposition and cannot be canceled.
  4. Their own response. The second one with a fall-rise, without adding any "but": the reservation goes in the melody.
  5. Their own response. An explicit and verifiable judgment is expected, which is what an honest reference demands.

ZARZA Studio — Your station on air today: library, music clock, schedule, studio and reports, from the browser.

Meet ZARZA Studio
— on air now — stations in the catalogue 2,021,834 podcasts — countries