Listen "Social Media Fundraising: Messaging Matters"
Episode Synopsis
In this episode of The First Day from The Fundraising School, host Bill Stanczykiewicz, Ed.D., welcomes Abhishek Bhati, Ph.D., Associate Professor at Bowling Green State University, to dive deep into the ever-buzzing world of social media fundraising. Spoiler alert, it’s not just about asking for money. Drawing on fresh research, Dr. Bhati reveals that nonprofits who blend a variety of six message types (instead of hammering the “donate now” button nonstop) can boost their fundraising results by a whopping 96%. That’s nearly doubling your impact just by mixing up your posts.
So, what are these six magical message types? Beneficiary stories, mission-focused content, engagement asks, expressions of gratitude, goal attainment updates, and fundraising ask. While asking remains the most frequent (and necessary) message, Dr. Bhati’s research shows that over-reliance on it can lead to donor fatigue faster than you can say “algorithm change.” It turns out donors want to feel part of a story, not just a transaction.
The conversation gets even juicier when Bill and Dr. Bhati dig into the science behind why these message types matter. Want more donations? Try publicly thanking donors (which can lift giving by 59%). Need to hit that campaign goal? Posts showing you’re just $50 short create FOMO that can spike donations by 79%. It’s all about creating that “whirlpool effect” of engagement, where your message spreads further and deeper.
They wrap with practical tips for fundraisers of all organizational sizes. Don’t have a massive marketing team? No problem. Start by planning posts ahead, use scheduling tools, and lean on your board, volunteers, and existing supporters to build your social media presence. Because as Dr. Bhati reminds us, social media fundraising isn’t a magic bullet, it’s a strategic dance. And when you choreograph your messages well, donors don’t just listen, they leap in.
So, what are these six magical message types? Beneficiary stories, mission-focused content, engagement asks, expressions of gratitude, goal attainment updates, and fundraising ask. While asking remains the most frequent (and necessary) message, Dr. Bhati’s research shows that over-reliance on it can lead to donor fatigue faster than you can say “algorithm change.” It turns out donors want to feel part of a story, not just a transaction.
The conversation gets even juicier when Bill and Dr. Bhati dig into the science behind why these message types matter. Want more donations? Try publicly thanking donors (which can lift giving by 59%). Need to hit that campaign goal? Posts showing you’re just $50 short create FOMO that can spike donations by 79%. It’s all about creating that “whirlpool effect” of engagement, where your message spreads further and deeper.
They wrap with practical tips for fundraisers of all organizational sizes. Don’t have a massive marketing team? No problem. Start by planning posts ahead, use scheduling tools, and lean on your board, volunteers, and existing supporters to build your social media presence. Because as Dr. Bhati reminds us, social media fundraising isn’t a magic bullet, it’s a strategic dance. And when you choreograph your messages well, donors don’t just listen, they leap in.
More episodes of the podcast First Day Podcast
Using AI to Strengthen Your Cause
23/11/2025
Latest Data on High Net Worth Donors
09/11/2025
Global Philanthropy Environment Index
02/11/2025
Building a Reserve Fund
26/10/2025
Women Donors in Seasons of Uncertainty
19/10/2025
Next Gen Donors the Inside Story
12/10/2025
Missing Our Mid-Level Donors
28/09/2025
Overcoming Burnout
21/09/2025
Bridging the Gap in Rural Philanthropy
14/09/2025
ZARZA We are Zarza, the prestigious firm behind major projects in information technology.